Lead I R-Wave Peak Time for Conduction System Capture in LBBAP
Authors, Journal, Affiliations, Type, DOI
- Authors: José Manuel Cubillas-Para, José Manuel Andreu-Cayuelas, María Eladia Salar-Alcaraz, Carmen Muñoz-Esparza, Ginés Elvira-Ruiz, Ignacio Jiménez-Zafra, and Pablo Peñafiel-Verdú
- Affiliations: Electrophysiology Unit, Cardiology Department, Virgen de la Arrixaca University Hospital, Murcia; Cardiology Department, Santa Lucía University Hospital, Cartagena, Spain
- Journal: Heart Rhythm, volume 23, number 10, October 2026, pages e2643–e2644
- Type: Retrospective, single-centre validation analysis reported as a research letter
- DOI: 10.1016/j.hrthm.2026.03.1950
- Funding and disclosure: No specific grant; the authors report no conflicts of interest
Overview
Lead V6 R-wave peak time is the workhorse criterion for left bundle branch capture, but its specificity collapses when V6 shows an rS morphology, and it varies with cycle length and respiration. This research letter externally validates lead I R-wave peak time as a substitute in 217 patients at one Spanish centre. Lead I outperformed lead V6 in every analysis: AUC 0.934 versus 0.807 in patients with a normal conduction system and 0.904 versus 0.895 in conduction system disease; Cohen's κ against the capture reference was 0.81 versus 0.59. The advantage was largest exactly where V6 fails — in patients with rS in V6, lead I kept 80% specificity while V6 fell to 10%. The study validates cut-offs proposed elsewhere rather than deriving new ones, and it is the first external test of those values.
Keywords
Left bundle branch pacing, conduction system capture, left septal pacing, R-wave peak time, lead I, lead V6, diagnostic accuracy, rS morphology
Key Takeaways
Rationale
- Up to one in five patients undergoing LBBAP have left septal pacing without conduction system capture, and distinguishing the two is the central intraprocedural problem
- V6 R-wave peak time is insufficiently specific when V6 shows rS morphology, and it varies with the stimulation cycle length and with respiration
- Lead I RWPT had been proposed to overcome the rS limitation, with published cut-offs of 81.5 ms (lead I) and 77.5 ms (lead V6) in patients with a normal conduction system, and 90.5 ms and 88.5 ms in those with conduction system disease
- Those cut-offs had been evaluated in only a single-centre derivation cohort. This study set out to validate them and to derive local optimal values
Design
- 217 patients from an initial 299 undergoing LBB area pacing at one tertiary centre; exclusions for implantation failure, unavailable technical data, or pacing configurations consistent with deep septal pacing
- Capture definition: a terminal r or R wave in lead V1 combined with established electrophysiological criteria — QRS morphology transition during unipolar threshold testing, or capture of a left bundle branch potential
- Left septal pacing: the same V1 morphology without fulfilment of the capture criteria
- Conduction system disease: LBB block or bifascicular block, nonspecific intraventricular conduction delay, wide QRS escape rhythm, or asystole
- Analyses were stratified by the presence of conduction system disease and by the presence of rS morphology in lead V6, and performance was tested both with locally derived cut-offs and with the previously published external cut-offs
Population
- 40.6% female; mean age 72.2 ± 10.1 years
- LVEF <40% in 19.4%, 40–52.9% in 20.3%, ≥52.9% in 60.4%
- Conduction system disease in 123 (56.7%); no conduction system disease in 94 (43.3%)
- Final pacing type: conduction system pacing 170 (78.3%), left septal pacing 47 (21.7%)
- rS morphology in V6 in 46 (21.2%), but in lead I in only 4 (1.8%)
Derived Optimal Cut-Offs
| Group | Lead | AUC | Cut-off | Sensitivity | Specificity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Normal conduction system | Lead I | 0.934 | 82 ms | 94.7% | 88.9% |
| Normal conduction system | Lead V6 | 0.807 | 80 ms | 90.7% | 66.7% |
| Normal conduction system, V6 rS excluded | Lead I | 0.934 | 82 ms | 93.2% | 84.6% |
| Normal conduction system, V6 rS excluded | Lead V6 | 0.915 | 80 ms | 88.1% | 92.3% |
| Conduction system disease | Lead I | 0.904 | 88 ms | 95.7% | 86.2% |
| Conduction system disease | Lead V6 | 0.895 | 80.5 ms | 85.9% | 86.2% |
| Conduction system disease, V6 rS excluded | Lead I | 0.959 | 88 ms | 94.4% | 91.7% |
| Conduction system disease, V6 rS excluded | Lead V6 | 0.959 | 85 ms | 88.9% | 95.8% |
- The locally derived cut-offs reproduce the published ones almost exactly — 82 ms versus 81.5 ms in normal conduction, 88 ms versus 90.5 ms in conduction system disease
- Excluding V6 rS rescues V6 but not to parity: V6's AUC rises from 0.807 to 0.915 in normal conduction, yet lead I still matches or beats it on every metric
Overall Performance
- Using locally derived cut-offs: lead I RWPT sensitivity 95.3%, specificity 87.2%, accuracy 93.6%, versus V6 86.5%, 78.9% and 84.8%
- Agreement with the reference standard: Cohen's κ 0.81 (95% CI 0.72–0.90) for lead I versus 0.59 (0.47–0.71) for V6
- Using the external cut-offs: lead I 95.3%/85.1%/93.1% with κ 0.80 (0.70–0.90); V6 92.4%/61.7%/85.7% with κ 0.56 (0.43–0.69)
- The differences in sensitivity and specificity between the two leads were statistically significant
The rS Subgroup — Where the Criterion Matters Most
- In patients with rS morphology in lead V6, using the derived cut-offs:
- Lead I: sensitivity 100%, specificity 80.0%, accuracy 95.7%
- Lead V6: sensitivity 100%, specificity 10.0%, accuracy 80.4%
- The accuracy difference was statistically significant, and the results were identical with the external cut-offs
- This is the reclamation of a defect already known: V6 keeps sensitivity in rS but its specificity becomes useless, meaning almost every patient is labelled as captured; lead I retains usable specificity
Interpretation
- The authors' summary: the optimal lead I cut-offs are consistent with those proposed externally; lead I RWPT performed better in the overall population and in the V6 rS subgroup; and lead I showed rS morphology roughly 12 times less often and never showed QS morphology
- The practical reading is that lead I does not replace V6 so much as cover the case V6 cannot handle — and that a criterion robust in rS morphology is worth having because the rS pattern was present in a fifth of this cohort
Limitations of the document
- Research letter format — four pages, with condensed methods and no supplementary diagnostic tables; the derivation and validation happen in the same cohort
- Retrospective and single-centre, at one Spanish tertiary centre, with no external validation cohort
- The reference standard is itself electrocardiographic: capture was defined by V1 morphology plus pacing-manoeuvre criteria, not by invasive His–Purkinje recording, so the new criterion is measured against the same class of surrogate as the one it replaces
- Only four patients had rS morphology in lead I, so the claim that lead I avoids the rS problem rests on a small number and cannot be examined in that subgroup
- The prevalence of V6 rS (21.2%) is higher than in the reference work, which may inflate the apparent advantage of lead I relative to the original derivation cohort
- No confidence intervals are reported for most sensitivity and specificity values, and no adjustment for multiple comparisons across the stratified analyses
- The population is a mixed indication cohort (bradycardia and CRT), so performance in a pure CRT or pure AV-block population is not separately reported
Key Concepts Mentioned
- concepts/LBBAP-Capture-Criteria — the page that owns the criterion comparison, where lead I now sits beside V6-RWPT, V6–V1 and the transseptal activation delta
- concepts/Left-Bundle-Branch-Area-Pacing — the parent procedure
- concepts/LBBAP-Implantation-Technique — the intraprocedural point at which activation time is measured
- concepts/Electrical-Resynchronization-Metrics — activation time as a surrogate for resynchronisation
- concepts/ECG-Conduction-Disturbances — the baseline QRS patterns that determine which lead is interpretable
Key Entities Mentioned
- None. The study uses several lead systems but reports no device-specific analysis
Wiki Pages Updated
wiki/sources/lead-i-rwpt-lbbap-hrs-2026.md— created (this page)wiki/concepts/LBBAP-Capture-Criteria.md— lead I RWPT subsection, master-comparison row, and one contradiction addedwiki/concepts/LBBAP-Implantation-Technique.md— depth-monitoring notes now include lead I as the fallback when V6 shows rSwiki/concepts/Left-Bundle-Branch-Area-Pacing.md— capture-criteria summary row addedwiki/sourceindex.md— index rowwiki/wikiindex.md— LBBAP-Capture-Criteria row revisedlog.md— ingest entry